Voice of Women
Issue no. 301
13 November 2008
In this issue:
* Jerusalemite women;, facts and challenges
* Light on the Palestinian women’s political experience
* Impact of the siege and political dispute on the women of Gaza
Jerusalemite women, facts and challenges
By: Sana' Anabtawi
Translated by: Samar Qutob
The issue of Jerusalem is a multi segment one where cultural, religious, nationalist and political elements are interrelated and affected by the ongoing struggle between the Christian and Muslim Palestinian inhabitants and the Israeli occupation.
When tackling the issue of Jerusalem, one would be discussing the land, the people, institutions, Islamic and Christian shrines, and the threatened Palestinian civilization and cultural heritage.
Jerusalem stands on the core of the Palestinian –Israeli struggle; a struggle that is getting heated day after day because of the illegal Israeli measures that started by joining East Jerusalem to Israel, and was followed by confiscating massive areas of the lands of Jerusalem, demolish Palestinians' houses, erecting the apartheid wall, and constructing Jewish settlements in and around the city. Isolating East Jerusalem from its Arab Palestinian surrounding was conceived by fencing the city with military checkpoints and posts and by introducing regulations to eliminate active economic, cultural and social institutes from the city.
The Palestinian strategic stand regarding the future of east Jerusalem is interrelated with the general Palestinian strategy on the Palestinian question; so, reaching a solution for Jerusalem is part of the whole national aspirations and goals that can only be interpreted through regaining our right for return, right in establishing our sovereign state with Jerusalem for it's capital, and the right of self determination.
The issue of Jerusalem is at the same time a key for any settlement to the Arab-Israeli conflict and for the prevalence of piece in the ME. However, local, regional and world's current status seems to be hindering the peace process and implementation of the international resolution regarding the Israeli withdrawal from the 1967 Palestinian territories including East Jerusalem.
Meanwhile, and until better conditions came to light, our national strategy must focus on "Maintaining and protecting the Arab Identity of East Jerusalem by supporting the steadfastness of the city's human, spiritual, and material resources; City should be given proper tools to be able to override Israeli occupation attempts to dilute the city's character and turn it to be totally reliant on the Israeli system". The following facts must be taken into accounts when drawing our national plan for Jerusalem:
-
East Jerusalem incubates the old city and several Palestinian rural, urban, and refugee residential areas. Civilians of those areas had been scattered and fractioned by the apartheid wall that placed 17% of theJerusalemites out of the cities metropolitan borders; Israeli occupation aims for a major demographic change that would bring the racial balance between the Arabs and Jews in 2020 to become 12% Arabs against 86 % Jews.
- The wall that is designed to swallow 72 square km from the Arab Jerusalemite lands has already consumed 26 square km of those areas; the wall and the introduced regulations and limitations have divided the Jerusalemites into two groups, a group with blue ID cards that are permitted to continue to reside in Jerusalem, and a group with West Bank ID cards that are denied any of the rights and benefits of the citizens of Jerusalem. Second group includes citizens of Al Izariyyah neighborhood, Abu Dis, Sawahreh, Anata, Hizma, sheikh Saied, Walageh, and the seven villages in the north- eastern basin of Jerusalem.
- Jerusalemites, although claimed to be in a better off status than west bankers, appear to be badly affected by the Israeli restricting regulations, the “blue ID cards” given to them might provide them with better mobility and with Israeli national security services, but on the other hand they are burdened with different types of taxes that reaches to about 33% of their incomes. Jerusalem municipality from its part spends only 8% of the cities services budget on the Arabs areas in the city.
- According to the Israeli National security statistics for the past two years, 60% of the Arab families in Jerusalem are under poverty line. Work opportunities available for women are very scarce and do not meet their educational and professional level. Arab women that need to start their private projects face so many obstacles and are hindered from applying for loans because of the high interests they have to pay and for the risks they need to take.
- Jerusalem women societies that provides vocational training are sticking to traditional jobs that do always meet the market demands, and when women approach the Israeli labor office for help, they are normally offered low standard jobs and lower salaries; domestic cleaning and farming are by large the jobs to be kept for Arab women.
- Regulations regarding house building or house expansions have led Jerusalemite families to be squeezed in small areas and crowded houses; the case is most obvious within the old city of Jerusalem. The Israeli settlements in and around the city were given massive lands from the Arab neighborhoods of Silwan, sheikh Jarrah, Shu’fat, Bet Hanina, and nabi Samoi’el in the old city; all on the expense of the Arabs areas and properties.
- The above social and financial problems were the main factors behind spread of social illnesses like dropping of girls from schools, early marriages, drugs and prostitution, honor killing, and environmental pollution.
- The Arab society in Jerusalem abstains from taking part in the formal Israeli political life; this also applies for women that have not been involved in the political life of the city and can’t participate in the political life in the West Bank as well because of their special status.
- In the 2005 Palestinian general elections, Israeli warning measures have prevented most Jerusalemites from taking part; only one woman from Jerusalem was elected for the Palestinian Legislative Council.
- A year ago, the National Conference for Jerusalem was formed to be the main reference body for the Arab people of Jerusalem; only 15% of the elected members were women.
Now, and as Jerusalem had been chosen for “The Arabs cultural capital in 2009”, it is hoped that Jerusalemite women as well as men would have better chances for engagement and participation in the huge workshops awaiting the city.
Light on the Palestinian women’s political experience
BY: Rima Kittaneh
Translated by: Samar Qutob
It has been three years since the 2nd Palestinian legislative council was elected, and 4 years since the first local councils for West Bank and Gaza governorates were elected. This reasonable period gives us some ground to read and evaluate the women’s share in the political Palestinian life as 527 women were elected for memberships in the local councils, and 17 were chosen for the National legislative council.
Evaluation showed that success and failure of the above mentioned women have been related to the individual women’s level of education and prior political experiences and involvement. However, parts of the results- success and failures alike have proved to be attributed to the internal and general political dispute in the Palestinian areas.
Women in the local councils:
- In general, evaluation found out that women members in big cities’ councils have registered better achievements than their colleagues in small rural and marginalized localities; this is partially due to personal capabilities and to social and cultural factors.
- Some women have been fully engaged in issues related to their posts, while most have limited themselves to issues related to the gender needs and interests; this was either because those women have narrow vision or because they were hindered by their mail colleagues that limited their area of work.
- At some stage, and due to the internal political dispute that erupted in the Palestinian areas after 2006, several local council members have resigned; women members were the most to resign and their move came individually sometimes, and as part of a collective measure by council members at other times.
- In several cases, resignations of women came because they were put under pressure by other members; council meetings were held at night or at times not suitable at all for mothers- members of council. Some women members stated that male colleagues used to meet behind their back. They discussed important issues and reach resolutions then bring papers to their female colleagues to sign; women claimed that an elimination policy had been followed against them.
- With regards to failures and successes, it had been noticed that women’s delivery was not isolated from the delivery of their councils; in successful councils women did well, and in falling councils their participation was below standard.
Women in the legislative council:
Palestinian women competed for the legislative council within 5 electoral lists; 8 women won in Fateh’s movement 28 seats list, 6 from Hamas 29 seats list, 2 independent, and one from the PFLP.
Evaluation of the women’s legislative experience is to be seen along with all National and political developments that appeared after the elections. Hamas, being the biggest winner in the general election has formed one colored Government and a legislative council with majority of members from the movement. This mad it hard to judge the individual achievement of the LC members and of the women members in particular; in general, council members, men and women can be accused of not meeting the voters’ expectations and aspiration. This could be referred to the following:
- The fact that general political disputes prevented the council from holding regular meeting and discussions.
- The drift between the council members that took the institute towards deep internal confrontations have paralyzed the council and destroyed all prospects of achievements by its members. Women members’ however were by large part of that confrontation, and did not put enough effort to narrow the gap between members or to search for common ground that could have united all members; small group of independent members spread a unifying massage within council , but their voices were hardly heard.
- Some women members from Hamas were detained by the Israeli occupation forces.
- Women members, by large have chosen to work and be involved in their local communities within the framework of their political parties- not according to their Parliamentary blocks; this was not always seen as a negative element as some members- especially in the West Bank were able to deliver strong political and humanitarian massages on Palestine to the Arab and International community.
Women in the political parties:
Palestinian women have always been involved in the political parties as most parties have affiliated women organizations. This led women’s political stands to be related to the parties’ sights and visions In all stages of the Palestinian political struggle.
However, status of the political parties in Palestine can currently be described to be retreating, and status of women party members have been affected as well. Social and economic collapses in the Palestinian areas have also affected status of the women in the political arena and have defused Palestinian women’s political organization and structures; Surfacing of tribal, traditional and patrioticrelations within countries of the region have left its deep marks on the Palestinian society and the Palestinian women movement and activities; women were the first to pay the price and to be pushed back behind closed doors.
Some light on causes of the retreat:
Oslo and the establishment of the first Palestinian Authority in the Palestinian areas was a big political turning point in the Palestinian history ; the PA was born with a unique structure that although not fully independent, includes some of the elements of independent states like ministries, judicial and security bodies, and police forces.
This structure however, has to deal with the fact that the Israeli occupation with its cruel and vicious practices persists and is capable of diluting all PA achievements in no time. Political parties have been alerted and confused and had to change its programs and priorities to try to face emerging challenges; women organizations within parties appeared to be drifting away and shrinking in the light of new developments.
- Women leaders by large withdrew from the political parties and joined the flourishing NGO’s that appeared to form better platforms for them at a certain stage.
- Some women activists decided to establish social centers and institutes as opposed to parties’ women organizations; step was seen as a trial activity in their quest to regain their fading power and influence.
- The expanding influence of Hamas and other Islamic groups led to surfacing of social and cultural centers related to those groups; although women’s status within those parties is not clear to us, it is obvious that large scale of the Palestinian women were employed by the parties affiliated bodies. Hamas was able to introduce quite a good number of women for the PLC elections.
- Retreat of the democratic programs of most political parties have led those parties to age and prevented the natural flow of new generation and new ideas to their premises. Fateh- the bigger and most influential movement appeared to be the most retreating. Absence of internal and organizational elections has driven younger generations away from the movement; young women in particular have shown less interest in joining such political bodies.
- The women leaders themselves were partially responsible for the retreat of the women’s political role as they did not put the needed effort to take them to higher positions; they did not show enough enthusiasm and did not lift their self capability to persuade the society of their abilities in leadership.
- Historically, women were given some leading positions in Fateh and some of the leftist parties like the PFLP and PDFLP. They were also given leading positions in some of the trade and youth unions. However, in most cases women’s presence appeared to be a decorative measure rather than functional. This is not to say that women in leading positions did not fight hard to prove their points, but rather to encourage them to work even harder to pave the way for the young generation of women.
Impact of the siege and political dispute on the women of Gaza
By: Majedah Abu Radwan
Translated by: Samar Qutob
The Political, militarily, and economic siege that have been imposed on the Palestinian areas is badly affecting status of the Palestinian women. Crises became worse in the past year as the Palestinian legislative, judicial, and executive bodies witnessed a split that have eventually led to the geographic split between Gaza and the West Bank.
The political role of the women of Gaza:
The women of Gaza have always been active and resistance to the Israeli occupation and military invasions of the stripes’ cities and villages. Women marches have always been the first to face the Israeli invading tanks and have always stood on front lines to protect their children with their chests and hands.
The latest political developments and the internal Palestinian dispute however appeared to be breaking the willingness of the women movement and have affected their activities. The General Union of the Palestinian women that played a major role in empowering women and uniting their activities have retreated after Hamas’s military coop in Gaza. Women activists have been targeted and threatened by Hamas members and were forced to hide underground.
The social retreat that accompanied Hamas military coop in Gaza has led to fading of the women’s role and activities; poverty and unemployment that hit Gaza badly have left women in the lowest social and legal position on the social ladder. Closure of most institutions in Gaza has led to discharge of employed women to bring unemployment percentage among the female society to 83% of the female working force. Thousands of the female graduates are forced to stay indoors and had to live under accumulated social and tribal pressures because of the new developments.
Housewives from their part were also affected by the siege, closures and economic retreat; women had to adjust to new rules of the housekeeping in the absence of fuel and electricity and scarcity of water and food supplies.
Violence and crimes against women:
Absence of law enforcement have led to the spread of criminal activities in Gaza, statistics of humanitarian and women bodies show that more women are killed “for Honor” in Gaza every day. A woman in her thirties was killed in Rafah last June because she got married against her family’s wish; the body of a woman that had been buried alive was found in the area.
The status co in Gaza with Hamas on head of the security forces have weakened the chances of the women in protection. Members of security forces could be ignorant and not aware of their role in this regard, or may be brainwashed by the party’s fundamental ideas and thoughts- specially the ones related to the women’s rights and status.
Women, being aware of the situation around them abstain from approaching the police or any of the judicial bodies for protection; women societies themselves were threatened and almost paralyzed by the new powers in Gaza and appear to be unable to protect or help the women in need.
One obvious reflection for the chaos in Gaza on women can be read in the family courts’ files as three hundred divorced unemployed mothers were to get monthly allowances from their ex husbands that are working in the West Bank to be able to care for their children, However, because of the siege, transferred money have not been delivered to those mothers as the Ministry of Finance in Ramallah refuses to deal with the courts in Gaza, and the women and children are left to face their destiny.
Hamas’s government in Gaza has introduced new regulations with regards to custody of children when parents are divorced; the women movement fought hard to achieve a regulation that gives divorced mothers the right in custody till children reach the age of 15, Hamas government in Gaza abolished the law and gave fathers the upper hand in this regards.
Details of violations of the women’s rights in Gaza are endless, but most important of all that those violations have been implemented by Hamas government as a revenge and response to unreceptive regulations taken by the government in Ramallah; women as usual were caught in the middle and were treated as the black sheep that had to pay the price